6 Comments
User's avatar
dogmawhistle's avatar

Good points re: school boards, but I wish that it had included questions and strategies for addressing Critical Race Theory in curriculums.

Expand full comment
Shane Trotter's avatar

Thank you for reading and commenting. I certainly share your concerns. Thus far this has not become an issue in the Dallas-Ft. Worth area (which is why it didn't show up in this Stuff) but I know it is in coastal cities. Still, its on my radar and one I address in my book and I'll probably address in a longer article in the future. For now, I'd point you to collect reasonable well spoken critics of the ideology who can be referenced and shared as a means of legitimizing/ clearly enunciating the profound issues. Some of the best include: John McWhorter, Shelby Steele, Thomas Sowell, Sam Harris, and Coleman Hughes. Hughes' latest podcast, which is a recording of his discussion at Harvard is phenomenal and has the legitimacy of a Harvard audience, whatever that is worth: https://youtu.be/Zq6xJ2vFlaA

Also, for a source that gets directly to your point, McWhorter addresses this here: https://johnmcwhorter.substack.com/p/is-it-racist-to-expect-black-kids

Quillette addresses the issue a bit as well and Megyn Kelly and Bill Maher have a fascinating discussion about it here: https://youtu.be/0pabbzNjZ2s

Thank you, again!

Expand full comment
dogmawhistle's avatar

thank you for your response. I follow all of the people you mention, as well as James Lindsey, Helen Pluckrose, Peter Boghossian, Brett Weinsteein, Glen Loury Karlyn Borsenko and Jodi Shaw. I'm surprised that the Dallas/Ft. Worth area is not yet dealing with CRT in curriculum, (Virignia ,Nevada, NH, Florida, and many other non-coastal places are in the thick of it.I'm not sure if geogrpahy matters much to me, in terms of IHD commenting on it, as IMO this is a national issue that has a strong growth and is supported by MSM, Big Tech upper academia and corporations. It is my wish that IDH may find a way to address CRT, even if it isn't yet in your backyard. Best.

Expand full comment
Shane Trotter's avatar

Yes, I agree. Geography only matters in regard to the initial prompt, which was the questions addressed to one specific local school board. But this is a national issue and one I'll plan to address in the future. I appreciate your writing.

Expand full comment
dogmawhistle's avatar

I appreciate your response...even if your p.o.v. might differ than mine, I'm happy just to get the conversation out there.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 24, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
dogmawhistle's avatar

Great point. I hope your suppositions about "actively combating it" are realized. The more that educators and parents start pushing back, the better. I have noticed that the CRT in education pushback is becoming more of a "thing." I'll take it. I'll take anything that evidences pushback.

Expand full comment